So, I cheated a little.
I had actually already decided which two books I was going to work on first before I posted the one-sentence blurb on each. However, I wanted to know what you thought...you know, which ideas* were intriguing.....that kind of thing.
And then I asked my 4th and 5th grade writing club what they thought.
You Guys = 4th and 5th graders!!
Far and away, the most intriguing (to the kids) concept was #4, Area 51 Elementary School. (You guys said the same!) I asked the kids what they liked, since the blurb is ultra-vague. Basically, they liked it because I told them to stop reading it. The more I told them I couldn't tell them about the stuff in the book, the more they wanted to know....kind of like the kid on the playground taunting, I've got a secret! I've got a secret!
In second place (among the 4th and 5th graders) was #1, Calista. They could not stopp asking questions about this one:
Mrs. Thomas, how did the girl lose her soul to the Lady of the Lake?
If the otter is a shape-shifter, why does it choose to be an otter?
This comment led to a 10 minute long debate about what could possibly be cooler than to be a shape-shifting otter.
This title also placed high with you guys, tying with the Willoughby Girls. (But a few of the boys in the club said that although they don't mind reading about girls, 4 was really an awful lot of them.)
Remarkably, I had already started #1 (because I wanted to spend a little more time in Celtic Folklore) and #4 because, well, it's Area 51. I probably shouldn't write about it....so I want to.
So, there you have it.
Kind of cool to know that you haveyour collective fingers on the pulse of the middle grade target audience!
And thanks to all of you who took the time to read and respond. I appreciate it more than you know.
*If you missed my 4 book idea blurbs, they are in the post below.